Rajkumar Hirani and Abhijat Joshi, in a conversation with Komal Nahta, opened up about the criticism they received for a particular scene in PK (2014). Aamir Khan, in the blockbuster, plays an alien who is searching for God. He comes across a stage artiste dressed as Lord Shiva. Mistaking him for God, PK confronts him and ends up chasing him. The sequence sparked controversy upon the film’s release, with a section of the audience finding it in bad taste.

When asked if they feared any backlash while writing the said scene, Rajkumar Hirani said, “We didn’t at all.” Abhijat Joshi added, “The person in question is not Lord Shiva at all. A stage play is going on. He’s an actor of that stage play who’s going to perform the role of Lord Shiva.” Rajkumar then said, “PK happens to assume that he’s God. There was no intention to make fun. We were making bigger points actually in the film…Issues, I guess, can happen with anything.”
Abhijat explained, “The intention of turning our protagonist into an alien is to make him see this question with a childlike innocence. Raju was very clear that with PK, we cannot be arrogant. People have some beliefs. We are raising some questions about these beliefs. But they need to be raised with innocence. It shouldn’t be arrogant or condescending. Hence, he’s an alien because he doesn’t know the concept of God at all.”
Rajkumar Hirani continued, “Hence, he’s questioning everything. Since he’s doing so with innocence, we also start questioning ourselves that, ‘Haan yaar, hum yeh kyun vishwas kar rahe hain?’. It’s not like the guy is saying ‘Yeh galat hai’.”
Abhijat Joshi stated, “So, it’s coming from a place of humility. We duly respect people’s sentiments. Hence, we were shocked (over the backlash). Phir gussa aata hai ki jo baat hai hi nahin, usko issue banaya gaya. We wrote and made the film with pure intentions.”


Comment
0Upholding journalistic discourse. No registration required.
No comments yet. Share your perspective!